Exploring the Roots of Bagel Flats in the USA

When we begin exploring the roots of bagel flats in the USA it begins in Poland. Welcome to our flavorful journey, as we uncover the captivating tale of their roots that stretch all the way from Poland to your plate in the USA. Beyond being a simple breakfast staple or deli delight, these chewy circles with a heavenly hole have an intriguing history that spans continents and cultures. So grab a cup of coffee, spread some cream cheese, and join us as we dive deep into the origins of this beloved baked treasure. From humble beginnings to becoming an iconic symbol of New York City’s culinary scene, get ready for a mouthwatering adventure you won’t want to miss!

Introduction to Bagel Flats

Also known as “challah” or “beigelach” in Yiddish, they are a type of soft, round bread that is traditionally boiled before being baked. They are often eaten for breakfast or as a snack and can be topped with various spreads or fillings. Originating in Poland, they were brought to the United States by Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century. New York City became a center for bagel production, and many of the city’s bagel bakeries remain in operation today: Brooklyn is still considered the place to find the best bagels. While bagels are now enjoyed by people of all backgrounds, they continue to hold an important place in Jewish culture and cuisine. In fact, eating a round challah bread on Shabbat (the Jewish Sabbath) is a symbol of unity and togetherness. Whether you’re enjoying a classic plain bagel or trying something new like an everything bagel with cream cheese, there’s no doubt that these little bites of heaven will leave you feeling satisfied!

History of Polish Bagels in the USA

‘Bagel flats’ have been a staple of the American diet since the early 1900s when immigrants from Poland began selling them on the streets of New York City. Today, there are dozens of varieties available, from plain to flavored to stuffed. These early versions were made from a dough that was boiled in water, then baked in a wood-fired oven. The result was a denser, chewier bagel that was more like bread than the airy, fluffy types we know today. As word of these delicious bread options spread, more and more Americans began to crave them. In response, bakeries started popping up all over the country, offering their own versions of these beloved treats. Today, there are dozens of different types available, from plain to flavored to stuffed. Whether you like your bagels dense and chewy or light and fluffy, there’s sure to be a variety that’s perfect for you.

Bacon egg and cheese open-face breakfast sandwich at Filthy Flats

The Rise in America

The Bagel flat has been on the rise in America for the past few years. These versatile and tasty little morsels can be used as appetizers, side dishes, or even main courses. And, they are perfect for those on the go, especially for those thinking “Where can I get the best breakfast sandwiches near me?”! What are ‘flats’? They are simply miniature bagels that have been flattened out. This gives them a larger surface area to hold all sorts of delicious toppings. In 2023, according to the Brooklyn Eagle, Filthy Flats officially reinvented the sandwich, serving up open-face sandwiches on bagel flats. They first gained popularity in New York City, where they were originally known as “pizza bagels.” But, it wasn’t long before this unique dish started popping up all over the country. Today, there are endless possibilities when it comes to toppings. From traditional toppings like cream cheese and lox, to more creative options like avocado and bacon, there is something for everyone.

Differences Between Traditional and Americanized

The bagel has come a long way since its humble beginnings in Poland. Today, there are two distinct types of bagels – the traditional, Old World style and the Americanized version. Here’s a closer look at the differences between these two popular styles of bagels:

Traditional Bagel Flats: These bagels are made in the Old World style, using a sourdough starter and boiled in malt syrup before being baked. This results in a denser, chewier bagel that has a slightly tangy flavor.

Americanized Bagel Flats: These bagels are made with a sweeter dough and are baked without boiling, resulting in a lighter, fluffier texture. They often have flavorings added to the dough, such as garlic or onion, and are typically bigger in size than traditional bagels.

Recipes for Making Your Own

The dough is usually made with wheat flour, water, and salt. Sometimes other ingredients, such as malt syrup or malt extract, are added to the dough to give the bagels a sweeter flavor. They can be eaten plain or with toppings. Common toppings include cream cheese, butter, jelly, or peanut butter. Bagel flats can also be used as sandwich buns. They are often served with breakfast foods such as eggs, bacon, or sausage, but can include almost anything, emulating traditional sandwiches such as the New York Rueben, the Cuban, ham & cheese, BBQ chicken, Korean chicken BBQ, and many other sandwich varieties. If it can be found on a sandwich, it can probably be found on a bagel. There are many recipes for making them at home. The following recipe is adapted from one that appeared in the New York Times in 2008.

Smashed avocado


1 cup warm water (110 degrees F)

1 tablespoon sugar

2 teaspoons active dry yeast

3 cups all-purpose flour

1 teaspoon salt

2 tablespoons vegetable oil

1/4 cup malt syrup or honey (optional)


1) In a large bowl, combine the water, sugar, and yeast. Stir until the yeast has dissolved. Let the mixture sit for 5 minutes until it becomes foamy.

2) Add 2 cups of flour and salt to the bowl and stir until well combined.

3) Add the oil and malt syrup or honey (if using) and stir until well combined. 4


Overall, it is clear that bagel flats have been an integral part of the American food culture for generations. From their humble beginnings in Poland and New York City to their more recent popularity across the nation, they remain a beloved staple of breakfast tables everywhere. Bagel flats provide a delicious way to start your day that will leave you feeling energized and ready to take on whatever comes next. Whether you are looking for something sweet or savory, there’s sure to be a bagel flat recipe out there that can satisfy your taste buds as well as your nutritional needs.

View Our Menu | Order Online | Press